Reason to trust
How Our News is Made
Strict editorial policy that focuses on accuracy, relevance, and impartiality
Ad discliamer
Morbi pretium leo et nisl aliquam mollis. Quisque arcu lorem, ultricies quis pellentesque nec, ullamcorper eu odio.
Bitcoin Core Developer and the Blockstream co-founder Gregory Maxwell explained how altcoins are distracting resources that could have been utilized to improve Bitcoin.
The celebrated techie, who was attending the launch of their pet project, the Sidechain Elements, criticized altcoins muddling the Bitcoin sector by creating an inessential competition. “I think the 2.0 space has, frankly, screwed up the 1.0 space by distracting talent, diverting money, misallocating infrastructure,” he explained. “And most of all, [it has confused] our message to the public (regarding bitcoin’s ability to store value, as the unique Internet money).”
Less Development, More Speculation
Maxwell noted that that a majority of the altcoin projects we come across nowadays are scams — some projects that sell infeasible ideas to lure investments, only to disappear with money in the end. And even if these projects appear to be genuine, investing into them doesn’t sound like a good idea. As per Maxwell, if a developer has a useful idea, he/she should simply try to have it add into the existing Bitcoin code.
He then blamed financial incentives the most, saying that a majority of altcoins work with a P&D mindset. Extracts from the presentation:
“Over time as people saw the potential value, they [people] started trading bitcoins for larger and larger amounts of money. So this creates the potential for a speculative race where people want to get in and hope that it becomes valuable in the future. And this has incentivized the creation of many altcoins, even ones that have no other reason for existing other than creating problematic pump and dumps.”
No Need for Another Bitcoin
There seems no point of adding more altcoins to the table, the opinion has been shared widely before Maxwell demonstrated his own. However, there are still many who are actually working towards the overall development of the cryptocurrency sector. For instance: Dash, aka Darkcoin, has literally improved privacy quo by introducing transaction obfuscation features, a thing that Maxwell himself discussed during his Sidechain Elements presentation.
With Bitcoin gaining mainstream adoption, the popularity of both good and bad altcoins have dried up anyways. Maxwell’s latest comments simply remind us of that.
Milly Bitcoin 
jimbit 
Spexx 
This is the same argument used by those involved in the legacy financial industry. They say Bitcoin is not needed and they are working on products and services that do the same thing. Gregory Maxwell is one of the people who has significant control over one of Bitcoin’s biggest chokepoints, the software development.
I agree that many alt coins are basically scams…BUT altcoins are the development ground for many innovations that bitcoin may never impliment: PPC with proof of stake, primecoin for discovering prime chains, DASH for instant confirmations, foldingcoin and curecoin for folding proteins.. just to name a few, there are many other innovations happening in the altcoin space… I call “cough.bull. cough sh. it
I am not surprised by Maxwell’s comments. He is simply trying to protect his pet project. Bitcoin showed us the way, but it is already a dinosaur lacking in innovation. In all the time of its existence, there has been no attempt to address the vulnerability to 51% attack and the amount of energy expended in mining Bitcoins has reached stupid proportions. It is basically a simple arms race with no end in sight. We need the innovations of altcoins to take us in a better direction. Proof-of-Stake has been a very important innovation that Bitcoin does not even plan to adopt, which is truly foolish. Hybrid Proof-of-Work/Proof-of-Stake altcoins are showing the way forward. There is currently only one altcoin which has addressed the problem of the mining arms race and you will be hearing more about that one as time goes on too.